For many Greenhill students, a trip to The Buzz is not complete without buying a cookie. Whether students are looking for a snack between classes or a treat after a long day, $1 cookies have become a popular choice.
The Buzz currently offers three flavors of Otis Spunkmeyer cookies: chocolate chip, sugar and carnival.
“The fastest selling cookie is going to be our chocolate chip cookie, hands down,” Campus Director Manager Anneli Phillip said.
Although chocolate chip remains the favorite, Phillip said that the popularity of other flavors sometimes changes throughout the school year. Carnival cookies occasionally become more popular and sugar cookies tend to sell better during the spring.
Sophomore Maahi Varma said that carnival is her favorite flavor because of its combination of flavors and colorful appearance.
“I think that it offers an interesting blend of different flavors, and I also like that it is colorful and attracts my eyes,” Varma said.
Sophomore Lorelei Stone says chocolate chip is her preferred flavor.
“Chocolate chip is my favorite because they taste the best and I like the contrast in textures. They’re usually the freshest because they’re so popular that they constantly have to make more batches,” Stone said.
The Buzz previously offered peanut butter cookies but discontinued them because they were not selling as well as the other flavors.
If The Buzz were to introduce another flavor, Varma said she would like to see a s’mores-inspired cookie featuring dark chocolate and marshmallow. Stone also suggested oatmeal raisin.
“I think it would be cool if The Buzz had a s’mores cookie with dark chocolate and marshmallow,” Varma said.
Behind the counter, preparing cookies is part of the staff’s daily routine. Philip bakes cookies every morning and try to prepare additional batches after Upper School breaks to meet student demand.
Phillip said that the cookies are especially popular among Middle School students, many of whom visit The Buzz with their parents or guardians in the afternoon.
Students have also experienced disappointment when their favorite cookies are unavailable.
“I once had a kid break into tears because there were no chocolate chip cookies,” Phillip said.
Along with their taste, the cookies’ $1 price contributes to their popularity. Phillip said that keeping the cookies affordable is important because students are more likely to purchase something they enjoy when it is inexpensive.
“There is a big margin between how much you love a product and how cheap it can be for your pocketbook,” Phillip said.
Varma said the price makes her more likely to buy cookies compared to other snacks at The Buzz. She also enjoys that the cookies are often served fresh from the oven.
“It definitely influences my decision to buy it more because it is cheaper than a lot of the other Buzz items,” Varma said.
While the cookies are a popular snack, Phillip said she has also noticed that students often purchase them depending on how their day is going. Some buy cookies to celebrate a good grade, while others stop by after a difficult day.
“I think when you guys have wins, like after a good exam or good feedback from a teacher, you guys want a cookie,” Phillip said. “It’s also one of those things where when you guys are having a really bad day, a cookie makes it better.”
With their affordable price and variety of flavors, The Buzz’s cookies continue to be a popular snack among students.
“Sometimes I buy a cookie to cheer myself up and make my day a little better,” Stone said.
