Upper School has integrated the artificial intelligence tool Claude into its student comment writing process with varying reactions from faculty members. Designed to reduce the time and cognitive effort needed to write comments, the framework aims to preserve each educator’s individual voice through a structured process, according to Middle and Upper School Educational Technologist Lane Worrall.
“Our goal was to empower teachers to draft the nuanced and meaningful, individualized comments that that they intended to write, but might not have had the time or space to fully develop for a large number of students in a condensed period of time,” Worrall said.
To help ensure the AI-generated drafts reflect individual writing styles, the school established a three-step process for educators.
First, teachers create personalized profiles within the system using examples of their previous writing. This allows Claude to learn their tone, vocabulary and writing style.
Next, educators provide specific notes and feedback about individual students’ performance.
Finally, Claude uses those details to generate an initial draft, which the teachers are expected to review, revise and finalize before submission.
“They’re not taking the output of AI and just sticking it in the comment box,” Worrall said. “It’s more of an intermediary piece that kind of helps them with their process.”
Not all faculty members are comfortable with AI playing a role in student feedback.
“I feel that I ask [students] to use their voice in photography in my classroom, and I’d like for them to hear mine,” Middle and Upper School photography teacher Frank Lopez said.
Although there is no formal system to prevent teachers from copying and pasting the AI-generated comments, the guidelines and expectations are clear: teachers remain responsible for the final feedback they submit, according to Worrall.
However, while Worrall emphasized teacher accountability in the process, some faculty members say they still have concerns.
“I think I would like a formal process of being able to say this was human-driven or AI-driven,” Lopez said. “I think that would be very helpful for those of us that take the time to custom write a comment.”
Lopez also expressed concern about the loss of creativity.
“Writing is an important part of the arts, and I think when we rely on AI, it dulls the senses,” Lopez said. “It allows me to not be as sharp as an educator, and that’s from the ‘me’ perspective.”
Worrall says the school plans to address these concerns through continued professional development and by encouraging teachers to be transparent with students about their use of AI.
AI literacy is a major part of a broader professional development series designed to help teachers understand how to use the technology appropriately, according to Worrall.
“We want them to model appropriate use with their students. So, if they’re using AI to build a lesson or to write a comment, they talk about that process with the students, so it’s not a breach of trust,” Worrall said.
Sophomore Olivia Bechtold agrees that transparency is important.
“I think that’s pretty much a major part of it,” Bechtold said, regarding transparency about AI use. “But I also think that AI should be almost equally available for students and teachers, and the expectations for that should be the same for both of them.”
Despite his concerns, Lopez acknowledges that AI has become an important part of our lives and says teachers should determine how best to incorporate it into their own practices.
“I think just to respect the human element of education,” Lopez said. “I mean that is my concern. You know, is to make sure that we are practicing authentically, listening authentically, and how do we help our people make good life decisions?”
Questions about student privacy and data security have also accompanied the school’s adoption of the tool. Worrall said a data privacy agreement with Anthropic, Claude’s developer, ensures that information entered through the school’s arrangement will not be use to train AI models.
After addressing these concerns, teachers also had positive feedback on the new tool.
“I spoke with some teachers that really felt empowered, and I think that was a big win for the students and the teachers,” Worrall said. “I think that the end goal is always to improve the student experience, and I feel like we were able to do that in some ways.”
